I feel stupid for asking this, but oh well here goes, I took advantage of that free .info domain thing that dotster was offering over a year ago. Now one of the 25 free ones I took I actually use and want to renew it. BUT I don't want to pay $14.95 at dotster, I'd rather pay like $8 at godaddy where I've bought all my other domains...
You can transfer your domain from dotster to godaddy and pay the godaddy reg fee to complete the transfer. Look in the faq's of both registrars to see how you can initiate this, I think it has to be done from godaddy in this case.